SteveWY... Having a #2 position in theory, is for a boat w/one battery switch and two battery banks...That being, either engine batteries or house batteries (everything else on boat)....Where, the #1 position controls battery bank #1 and the #2 position controls battery bank #2...and the "all" position , being similar to "Paralleling" (tying) both #1 & #2 battery banks together to start either engine....What it appears is happening on your BT is; they wired each engine to the #1 terminal on each switch...(i.e. port switch position #1 energizes the port engine from the port battery bank and starboard switch #1 position energizes the starboard engine from starboard battery bank)....That is probably because, all battery switches are manufactured in basically the same configuration (off, 1, 2 and all)... and since you have two engines, you have two separate switches controlling each of the separate battery banks...Now, I'm sure you have a generator, which, should have it's own battery and switch...But, If I were you I would check to make sure the "ALL" position on both switches works to parallel (tie) both battery banks correctly...To do this, put both switches in the "all" position, then disconnect the positive (red) battery cable from one of the battery banks (let's say port), then try to start each engine, one-at-a-time....both engines should start...Now, reconnect the port (red) battery cable and repeat this process with the starboard battery bank...again, both engines should start, one at a time....FYI...if you are ever out on the water and you run your batteries down with massive audio amps, lighting and etc....You can always use your "Genny" to help one engine start, then the next... In addition, I would recommend that you do as Phragle suggested...Just get in there and follow the wires...This will help you to know exactly what is running what...in addition, I would suggest keeping a "CHARGED" portable battery booster box and/or 2000 watt Honda portable generator onboard, not only for your "peace of mind", but, to help others cruising with you, should the need arise.... After many years of boating/towing/rescue and marine salvage, I have seen and done it all... and most of my boating friends, I met by boating accident or mishap (pun intended)...There are few things worse, than a "No start or low start situation" while cruising/travelling and "I'd rather be safe than sorry..In fact, I carry a set of 20ft booster cables as well...Hope I haven't been overly wordy... Call me @ 313-510-2208 and I'll swing by your way...I'd like to see your new set-up anyway (Hoist, Boat, bow thruster, etc...)...
Divenstar