I realize that this would have been the guys first assault and murder but, don't even get me started on the fact that if it was for real he wouldn't have ordered JACK and had a record that he was ever there. He also wouldn't have left her within easy view of the pizza man, unless it was a game.
And a rental car? Rented in his own name? Let me guess.... he put the cabin rental on his credit card?
The fact that the woman has made false reports in the past does not even factor for me. It is the other logic problems. Because even somebody who has faked it can have it happen for real.
I mean, she was able to mouth stuff to the pizza guy? Come on.
If this guy was an actual killer the woman and the pizza guy would both be missing and the kidnapper would have an alibi.
To me, it smells like a bad idea sounded good, at first. Then it sounded bad.